Fehler in nlme wiederholte Maßnahmen

Question

Ich versuche, ein lineares gemischtes Modell mit wiederholten Messungen zu 57 verschiedenen Zeitpunkten zu laufen. Aber ich erhalte immer die Fehlermeldung:

Error in solve.default(estimates[dimE[1L] - (p:1), dimE[2L] - (p:1), drop = FALSE]) : 

System ist rechnerisch Singular: gegenseitige Bedingung Nummer = 7.7782e-18

Was bedeutet das?

Mein Code ist so:

model.dataset = data.frame(TimepointM=timepoint,SubjectM=sample,GeneM=gene) 
library("nlme") 
model = lme(score ~ TimepointM + GeneM,data=model.dataset,random = ~1|SubjectM)  

Hier die Daten:

score = c(2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,6,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7,2,-3,11,14,1,7) 
timepoint = c(1,1,1,1,1,1,2,2,2,2,2,2,3,3,3,3,3,3,3,4,4,4,4,4,4,5,5,5,5,5,5,6,6,6,6,6,6,7,7,7,7,7,7,8,8,8,8,8,8,8,9,9,9,9,9,9,10,10,10,10,10,10,10,12,12,12,12,12,12,12,12,13,13,13,13,13,13,13,13,14,14,14,14,14,14,14,14,15,15,15,15,15,15,16,16,16,16,16,16,16,16,17,17,17,17,17,17,18,18,18,18,18,18,19,19,19,19,19,19,19,20,20,20,20,20,20,21,21,21,21,21,21,24,24,24,24,24,24,24,25,25,25,25,25,25,25,27,27,27,27,27,27,28,28,28,28,28,28,29,29,29,29,29,29,30,30,30,30,30,30,30,31,31,31,31,31,31,31,32,32,32,32,32,32,33,33,33,33,33,33,33,33,34,34,34,34,34,34,34,35,35,35,35,35,35,36,36,36,36,36,36,36,37,37,37,37,37,37,38,38,38,38,38,38,39,39,39,39,39,39,39,40,40,40,40,40,40,40,41,41,41,41,41,41,41,41,42,42,42,42,42,42,42,42,43,43,43,43,43,43,44,44,44,44,44,44,44,45,45,45,45,45,45,46,46,46,46,46,46,47,47,47,47,47,47,48,48,48,48,48,48,49,49,49,49,49,49,49,50,50,50,50,50,50,51,51,51,51,51,51,52,52,52,52,52,52,52,53,53,53,53,53,53,53,54,54,54,54,54,54,55,55,55,55,55,55,56,56,56,56,56,56,57,57,57,57,57,57) 
sample = c("S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S13T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S01T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0","S02T0","S03T0","S07T0","S09T0","S10T0","S12T0") 
gene =c(24.1215870,-18.8771658,-27.3747309,-41.5740199,26.1561877,-2.7836332,20.8322796,36.5745088,-24.1541743,-11.2362216,4.9042852,7.4230219,155.8663563,16.4465366,-11.7982286,-1.6102783,-35.9559091,27.7909495,-13.9181661,-29.6037658,-68.4297261,-45.0877920,-48.3157529,17.1649982,-26.9084544,19.7358439,-5.8991143,-24.1541743,-23.5960654,13.0780939,-2.7836332,18.6394081,-28.3157487,-49.9186269,-33.7086648,41.6864242,-30.6199654,36.1823804,-36.5745088,-49.9186269,-44.9448864,-4.9042852,-34.3314764,62.3465425,-42.7609951,-11.7982286,-32.2055657,-56.1811080,5.7216661,-17.6296771,4.3857431,-43.6534459,9.6616697,-44.9448864,18.7997599,-12.9902884,109.1064494,7.6750504,-43.6534459,-17.7130611,-25.8433097,5.7216661,-18.5575548,35.2750175,36.1823804,2.3596457,-25.7644526,-55.0574858,15.5302365,-19.4854325,73.3687689,63.1668918,20.8322796,16.5175201,-22.5438960,-28.0905540,15.5302365,7.4230219,39.5062602,107.4657509,36.1823804,-23.5964573,-45.0877920,-43.8212642,4.0869043,-40.8266205,26.3375068,13.1572292,-25.9561030,-40.2569571,-52.8102415,2.4521426,-49.1775202,246.1047731,36.1823804,11.7982286,-35.4261223,-26.9669318,-2.4521426,-38.0429873,38.5656349,9.8679219,16.5175201,8.0513914,-42.6976421,26.9735686,-26.9084544,4.3857431,12.9780515,-32.2055657,-33.7086648,9.8085704,-36.2800196,215.7518511,6.5786146,-9.4385829,-19.3233394,-40.4503978,17.1649982,-7.4230219,14.2536650,-23.5964573,-53.1391834,-52.8102415,22.0692834,-54.7447866,24.1215870,-44.8332688,-24.1541743,-42.6976421,26.9735686,-40.8266205,191.1413737,17.5429723,-70.7893718,-37.0364006,-39.3267756,-4.9042852,-0.9278777,93.5198138,-6.5786146,-24.7762801,-28.9850091,-39.3267756,22.0692834,-50.1053979,14.2536650,23.5964573,-20.9336177,-53.9338637,14.7128556,-39.8987428,4.3857431,-64.8902575,-59.5802966,-33.7086648,22.0692834,2.7836332,46.0503024,-35.3946859,-43.4775137,-53.9338637,30.2430921,-34.3314764,80.3942259,28.5073300,-87.3068919,-24.1541743,-62.9228410,13.0780939,-25.0526990,35.0859447,-24.7762801,-38.6466789,-58.4283523,31.0604729,0.0000000,24.4562563,1.0964358,-27.1359259,-75.6830794,-16.8543324,20.4345217,-11.1345329,74.1390629,18.2282447,-27.3044720,-45.2890768,-46.7707724,15.3258912,-27.9523169,-6.9763039,117.3099418,18.6394081,-21.2368115,-38.6466789,-34.8322870,22.0692834,-48.2496425,6.5786146,-64.8902575,-51.5289052,-80.9007955,23.7040451,-26.9084544,223.1349942,8.7714862,10.6184058,-127.2119846,-31.4614205,0.8173809,-16.7017993,9.8679219,-35.3946859,-54.7494617,-44.9448864,14.7128556,-18.5575548,97.5827836,-166.3550237,-95.0064189,-123.5984376,104.6247509,-121.5519839,33.9895089,-44.8332688,-40.2569571,-56.1811080,51.4949946,0.0000000,-16.9312544,95.9808615,6.5786146,-21.2368115,-9.6616697,-13.4834659,10.6259513,-25.9805767,116.4895926,-1.0964358,-16.5175201,-56.3597400,-44.9448864,13.8954747,-12.9902884,-5.6437515,71.3703842,25.2180227,-41.2938002,-53.1391834,-32.5850426,8.9911895,12.9902884,31.9812582,1.0964358,-70.7893718,-33.8158440,-38.2031534,-15.5302365,-25.0526990,153.4053085,36.1823804,-34.2148630,-41.8672354,-19.1015767,22.8866643,0.9278777,20.8322796,-29.4955716,-43.4775137,-69.6645739,33.5126155,-45.4660092,26.3144585,-33.0350402,24.1541743,-42.6976421,0.0000000,-28.7642099,38.3752520,-7.0789372,-22.5438960,-20.2251989,34.3299964,19.4854325,4.3857431,-61.3507889,-33.8158440,-64.0464631,39.2342816,-28.7642099,183.7582306,-4.3857431,-22.4166344,-28.9850091,-57.3047302,25.3388069,-26.9084544,35.0859447,7.0789372,-33.8158440,-43.8212642,-1.6347617,5.5672664,-35.0859447,-40.1139773,-14.4925046,-12.3598438,21.2519025,-14.8460438,119.7709896,30.7002016,-22.4166344,-46.6980703,-43.8212642,5.7216661,-10.2066551,203.4466124,116.2221917,-83.7674233,-109.4989234,-38.2031534,78.4685632,-56.6005421,21.9287154,-63.7104346,-56.3597400,-4.4944886,25.3388069,-73.3023414,29.6037658,-31.8552173,-46.6980703,-79.7771734,21.2519025,-18.5575548,16.4465366,-27.1359259,-43.4775137,-41.5740199,-11.4433321,-23.1969435,27.4108943,-84.9472461,-53.1391834,-40.4503978,22.8866643,16.7017993) 

Answer 1

tl; dr Ich denke, Ihr Problem ist, dass jeder einzelne hat genau den gleichen Antwortwert (score) für jeden Zeitpunkt (dh perfekte Homogenität innerhalb von Individuen), so erklärt der Random-Effects-Begriff die Daten vollständig; Für die fixen Effekte ist nichts mehr übrig. Sind Sie sicher, dass Sie nicht gene als Antwortvariable verwenden möchten? (Entdeckt nachdem sie durch eine Reihe von Modellversuchen liefen, durch Plotten der verdammten Daten, soll etwas, das jeder tut immer zuerst ...)

## simplifying names etc. slightly 
dd <- data.frame(timepoint,sample,gene,score,) 
library("nlme") 
m0 <- lme(score ~ timepoint + gene, data=dd, 
    random = ~1|sample) 
## reproduces error 

Als erste Prüfung, lassen Sie sie sieht, wenn es etwas in Ihrem festen ist -Effect-Modell, das Singular ist:

lm(score~timepoint+gene,dd) 
## 
## Call: 
## lm(formula = score ~ timepoint + gene, data = dd) 
## 
## Coefficients: 
## (Intercept) timepoint   gene 
## 5.414652 -0.004064 -0.024485 

Nein, das funktioniert gut.

Versuchen wir es in lme4:

library(lme4) 
m1 <- lmer(score ~ timepoint + gene + (1|sample), data=dd) 
## Error in fn(x, ...) : Downdated VtV is not positive definite 

versuchen Lassen & Skalierung der Datenzentrieren - manchmal, das hilft:

ddsc <- transform(dd, 
    timepoint=scale(timepoint), 
    gene=scale(gene)) 

lme immer noch nicht:

m0sc <- lme(score ~ timepoint + gene, data=ddsc, 
    random = ~1|sample) 

lmer Werke - s oder von!

Die Ergebnisse geben Koeffizienten für die Parameter an, die verschwindend nahe bei Null liegen. (Die Residualvarianz ist auch verschwindend klein.)

## m1sc 
## Linear mixed model fit by REML ['lmerMod'] 
## Formula: score ~ timepoint + gene + (1 | sample) 
## Data: ddsc 
## REML criterion at convergence: -9062.721 
## Random effects: 
## Groups Name  Std.Dev. 
## sample (Intercept) 7.838e-01 
## Residual    3.344e-07 
## Number of obs: 348, groups: sample, 8 
## Fixed Effects: 
## (Intercept) timepoint   gene 
## 5.714e+00 -4.194e-16 -1.032e-14 

An diesem Punkt habe ich nur ein paar Möglichkeiten denken:

• gibt es etwas über das experimentelle Design, das bedeutet, dass die zufällige Effekte irgendwie sind (?) vollständig mit einem oder beiden der festen Effekte verwechselt
• das sind simulierte Daten, die künstlich konstruiert sind, um perfekt ausgeglichen zu sein ...?

library(ggplot2); theme_set(theme_bw()) 
ggplot(dd,aes(timepoint,score,group=sample,colour=gene))+ 
     geom_point(size=4)+ 
     geom_line(colour="red",alpha=0.5) 

Aha!

Answer 2

Damit R eine Matrix lösen kann, muss es rekursiv invertierbar sein. Der Fehler, den Sie erhalten, sagt Ihnen, dass Ihre Matrix für Rechenzwecke singulär ist, was bedeutet, dass sie keine Inverse hat.

Da dieser Fehler eher die statistische Theorie betrifft, ist er wahrscheinlich besser für die Kreuzvalidierung geeignet. Weitere Informationen finden Sie unter this link.

Überprüfen Sie Ihre Daten, um sicherzustellen, dass Sie keine perfekt korrelierten unabhängigen Variablen haben.